Selective Outcome Reporting (SOR) in Pediatric Dentistry restorative treatment Randomized Clinical Trials - A systematic Review (2021)
- Authors:
- USP affiliated authors: PANNUTI, CLAUDIO MENDES - FO ; MENDES, FAUSTO MEDEIROS - FO ; FRAGA, MARIANA MINATEL BRAGA - FO ; RAGGIO, DANIELA PRÓCIDA - FO
- Unidade: FO
- Subjects: RELATÓRIOS; RESTAURAÇÃO DENTÁRIA; ODONTOPEDIATRIA; REVISÃO SISTEMÁTICA
- Language: Português
- Abstract: We aimed to evaluate the prevalence of SOR in the randomized clinical trials focusing on restorative treatment in primary molars. We searched for RCTs protocol registries in the ClinicalTrials.gov and WHO platform up to April/2021. We included any study classified as an RCT, with two or more experimental arms that evaluated any restorative treatment on primary teeth. The registries that did not result in any publications were excluded. Our search strategy identified 294 registries and 31 publications were included for data extraction. We have also calculated the median of journals' impact factors. Chi-square test was performed with 5% significance level. Our results found that the prevalence of SOR was identified in 19 papers (61.3%). The most common reason was a discrepancy in the primary outcome timeframe (48.4%). Twenty-six (83.9%) of the trials were registered retrospectively. Also, a discrepancy in sponsorship was identified in 22 (71%) of the trials. SOR was associated with the discrepancy in the follow-up period (p=0.003), with no association with registration timing (p=0.948). The impact factor of the journals ranged from 0.213 - 5.79. We found SOR in 9 (29%) of the six high impact factor journals and 10 (32.3%) of the eight with low impact. Consequently, we emphasized the importance of transparency in RCT focusing on restorative care in children, including properly prospective registration and declaration of any discrepancy in the final manuscript, helping to avoid spin in science
- Imprenta:
- Source:
- Título do periódico: Brazilian Oral Research
- ISSN: 1807-3107
- Volume/Número/Paginação/Ano: v. 35, supl. 3, p. 74, res. HA006, 2021
- Conference titles: Proceedings of the SBPqO Annual Meeting
-
ABNT
ELAGAMI, R. A et al. Selective Outcome Reporting (SOR) in Pediatric Dentistry restorative treatment Randomized Clinical Trials - A systematic Review. Brazilian Oral Research. São Paulo: SBPqO. . Acesso em: 10 jun. 2024. , 2021 -
APA
Elagami, R. A., Tedesco, T. K., Pannuti, C. M., Seabra, G., Fraga, M. M. B., Mendes, F. M., & Raggio, D. P. (2021). Selective Outcome Reporting (SOR) in Pediatric Dentistry restorative treatment Randomized Clinical Trials - A systematic Review. Brazilian Oral Research. São Paulo: SBPqO. -
NLM
Elagami RA, Tedesco TK, Pannuti CM, Seabra G, Fraga MMB, Mendes FM, Raggio DP. Selective Outcome Reporting (SOR) in Pediatric Dentistry restorative treatment Randomized Clinical Trials - A systematic Review. Brazilian Oral Research. 2021 ; 35 74.[citado 2024 jun. 10 ] -
Vancouver
Elagami RA, Tedesco TK, Pannuti CM, Seabra G, Fraga MMB, Mendes FM, Raggio DP. Selective Outcome Reporting (SOR) in Pediatric Dentistry restorative treatment Randomized Clinical Trials - A systematic Review. Brazilian Oral Research. 2021 ; 35 74.[citado 2024 jun. 10 ] - Impacto do exame radiográfico no diagnóstico e decisão de tratamento de lesões de cárie em dentes decíduos - CARies DEtection in Children 01
- Influência da zigosidade no medo e ansiedade de crianças frente ao ambiente odontológico: estudo de coorte em gêmeos
- Do the clinical practice guidelines for paediatric dentistry meet the quality standards?: a metaresearch and quality appraisal using AGREE II tool
- What is the impact of the diagnosis and treatment of active initial caries lesions in primary teeth on further dental needs alongside 1 year?
- Impacto do exame radiográfico no diagnóstico e decisão de tratamento de lesões de cárie em dentes decíduos
- Utilização de escores de utilidade baseados em questionário de qualidade de vida associado à saúde bucal em avaliações econômicas
- Variáveis de Qualidade de Vida Relacionada à Saúde Bucal de pré-escolares refletem desfechos clínicos sobre cárie dentária?
- A hall technique como estratégia no manejo de lesões ocluso-proximais em molares decíduos: 3 anos de um ensaio clínico randomizado
- Cimento de Ionômero de Vidro Pó-Líquido (PL) ou Encapsulado (ENC)? - Análise Econômica de um Estudo Clínico Randomizado (ECR)
- Impact of the radiographic method on treatment decisions related to dental caries in primary molars: a before–after study
How to cite
A citação é gerada automaticamente e pode não estar totalmente de acordo com as normas
